New Giuliani Flip-Flop: Immigration

For indispensable reporting on the coronavirus crisis, the election, and more, subscribe to the Mother Jones Daily newsletter.


This one’s a doozy, maybe bigger than his flip-flops on the flat tax and on abortion.

Here’s what Giuliani said in a 1996 speech at Harvard:

We’re never, ever going to be able to totally control immigration to a country that is as large as ours, that has borders that are as diverse as the borders of the United States, and as a society that wants to be a country that values freedom — that values freedom of movement, freedom to do business.

See video at TPM’s Election Central. This is part of Giuliani’s formerly understanding view of immigration and immigrants: Giuliani’s New York gave many of the same benefits to citizens and illegal immigrants; Giuliani took strong measures to educate the children of illegal immigrants; he fought to keep illegal immigrants from being turned in by employers. Of conservativism’s hardline anti-immigrant forces, Giuliani has said, “the anti-immigration movement now sweeping the country is no different than earlier anti-immigration movements that have surfaced periodically in American history. We need only look back at the ‘Chinese Exclusionary Act’ or especially at the ‘Know-nothing’ movement that swept America in the mid-19th century.”

Kind of a good dude, right? Unfortunately, all this contrasts with Giuliani’s views today. In a recent speech in South Carolina, Giuliani contradicted the Harvard speech, saying, “We can end illegal immigration. I promise you we can end illegal immigration.” The former mayor now advocates building a physical fence between the U.S. and Mexico.

Willing to forgive what appears to be a simple change of heart? I understand. I wouldn’t slam the man if he said, “I’ve seen new evidence since ’96, illegal immigration has gotten much worse, we need to do something.” But Giuliani’s rhetoric on immigration these days is so extreme and xenophobic that the man deserves no harbor. Giuliani’s plan, according to his own press release, includes a “tamper-proof Secure Authorized Foreign Entry Card (SAFE Card) for all foreign workers and students, a single national database of non-citizens to track their status, and tracking those who leave the country. In addition, Giuliani will encourage Americanization by requiring immigrants to truly read, write and speak English.”

He wants a database of all foreigners in the United States! And he wants to somehow force-teach them all English! He is the Know-nothing he once derided!

This is a very different Rudy Giuliani than the one from ten years ago. Running for president will do that to a man.

DOES IT FEEL LIKE POLITICS IS AT A BREAKING POINT?

Headshot of Editor in Chief of Mother Jones, Clara Jeffery

It sure feels that way to me, and here at Mother Jones, we’ve been thinking a lot about what journalism needs to do differently, and how we can have the biggest impact.

We kept coming back to one word: corruption. Democracy and the rule of law being undermined by those with wealth and power for their own gain. So we're launching an ambitious Mother Jones Corruption Project to do deep, time-intensive reporting on systemic corruption, and asking the MoJo community to help crowdfund it.

We aim to hire, build a team, and give them the time and space needed to understand how we got here and how we might get out. We want to dig into the forces and decisions that have allowed massive conflicts of interest, influence peddling, and win-at-all-costs politics to flourish.

It's unlike anything we've done, and we have seed funding to get started, but we're looking to raise $500,000 from readers by July when we'll be making key budgeting decisions—and the more resources we have by then, the deeper we can dig. If our plan sounds good to you, please help kickstart it with a tax-deductible donation today.

Thanks for reading—whether or not you can pitch in today, or ever, I'm glad you're with us.

Signed by Clara Jeffery

Clara Jeffery, Editor-in-Chief

payment methods

We Recommend

Latest